I love themed fic listed. I think that people who compile such lists (hi
korilian ^_^) are wonderful. Not only are these list a great tool for finding stories I can't quite remember the title or author of, they also cater directly to my joy in reading fifteen bajillion takes on whatever plot I'm currently obsessed with.
I've been playing in Harry Potter fandom lately, and I've come across one such wonderful person, who goes by
painless_j She has made MANY themed lists, has a list of other people's themed lists, and link the a couple other people's lists of other people's themed lists. Dayenu, but she's also cross-referenced her themed lists with her recs. Have I mentioned I also love rec lists? She's great!
But this is where it gets a bit odd. Granted, different people have different tastes in stories, but one would think that if you come down to something as specific as "HP gen fanfic portraying Severus Snape at an age younger than 11", there should be a good amount of agreement as to what is a good story in the genre. But not so. A number of stories I like failed to get her recommendation. That, I sort of understand. Two people might not love the same stories, even if they both sort of like them. However, she's also recced a couple stories that I disliked to the extent that I couldn't finish them. And it takes a LOT to stop me reading a story that fits my current OCD.
This finding has now sparked the interest of my inner anthropologist. I had previously thought enjoyment of a story was a simple matter of liking of the theme plus quality of writing. Obvious, this equation is overly simplistic, or
painless_j and I would be in perfect agreement on what constituted a good child-Snape story. What then can account for such disparate views? Is it rather some complex calculus on the number of overlapping genre likes and priming on one's opinion of the the author with adjustment for preferred story length divided by the ratio of word to grammar errors multiplied by a tolerance variable and....
Did I mention my inner anthropologist is kind of a geek?